This is HCD runs a free membership community on Circle: courses, a podcast, mentorship and a members’ feed. Members loved the courses — but the community was quiet. I interviewed members to find out why, and what would make them stay and pay.
One-to-one interviews with members at different stages. One interviewee also moderated the community, so I kept that admin view separate and analysed the other five as members.
Every quote went on a sticky, colour-coded by participant, so I could see whether a theme came from one loud voice or from everyone. Then I regrouped them into themes, and themes into five insights.



Five insights, ordered from biggest risk to biggest strength.
Pick a theme to see the evidence behind the insights.
Every recommendation answers one of the insights — and none of them needs a new platform.